One of my best friends … and incidentally, also my first boyfriend … writes me this week about his girl troubles. He’s dating a girl who, by his own admission, is highly unstable and wildly volatile. She has a host of mental issues, often resists medication, and fluctuates from here to forever but—he assures me—loves him fiercely. So fiercely that she’s thrice tried to kill herself when he goes out of town, or when they fight; when she feels unsure, the paramedics come. Trouble. It’s all I can do to keep from screaming BREAK UP WITH HER NOW—because I’ve done that, plenty of times over their three years together. He knows how I feel. She is precious, of that I have no doubt, but she needs far, far more help than he can give. And yet, he tells me, they’re moving in together next month. “I’m worried that it’s too soon, and I’m still not sure about this relationship,” he said. “But she needs me.” He isn’t answering his phone.
A friend of mine from school got engaged this weekend, to a guy she’s been dating since I’ve known her. Nice guy; always been really good to her, and to me. Something about him just doesn’t seem right for her, though. I’ve never thought so. Actually, I’ve always thought he was kind of a well-intentioned loser. She’s so dynamic, so lovely; he’s so mediocre. I think she can do so much better, but I’m not confident she sees the girl I do when I look at her. I’ve tried to talk to her at various points about how their relationship is going, to suss out whether she’s really happy; I feel like she is, but only on the surface. She wants a wedding. She wants to be loved. We all do, on some level, but where do you draw the line? When do you say, sister, stop pining after a loser, you are fabulous? I can’t know the whole story, none of us ever can. Maybe he is perfect for her: I’ve just never, ever bought it. He finally did the whole get-down-on-one-knee thing, and of course she said yes. Honestly, I was kind of hoping that he never would, and she’d move on. How could I have said that, though, without looking like the bitter and jaded single friend? I’m not jealous of her relationship. Maybe it’s just that I know something about settling for what you think makes you happy, without considering what real happiness looks like. I’m working on putting on a real smile for them.
The India trip my church has asked me to go on is a week-long trip as ambassadors of the Anglican district of Virginia (and yes, I still consider myself Catholic; crazy, I know). We’ll visit churches there, and say hello from the fair commonwealth; we’ll learn about them, and they about us. Excellent, I think. At a planning meeting yesterday, the leading priest asked us to give our testimonies—to tell our stories of how we found God. I grew up Christian, which is not a very interesting tale. Instead, I described how I found God as an adult—which (regrettably) is essentially a march through the big mistakes of my relationships gone totally bust. The Japan man started it off, of course. Then the whole almost-getting-engaged-to-J thing. I screwed up, and God found me. True, but not necessarily a fun story to tell a room full of people you barely know (especially when one of them is actually a pretty good-looking single smartie—a PhD, he has! Hooray! I’m going to work on sitting next to him on the long flight, mmm-hmmm). It gets better, though. The priest calls my story “inspiring,” then tells us we’ll all be sharing our testimonies in India, IN FRONT OF A CONFERENCE OF INDIAN BISHOPS. Hi, I’m magda, and I suck at relationships. God’s found me after I’ve f’d everything up, in all possible ways. Nice to meet you, too.
The PhD smartie sent me a really nice e-mail after the meeting, saying he wished we could have had more time to talk, and hoping I had a nice time in Boston last week. As I was writing back, a new message came in. From the Japan man. He’s “decided to kill some time by taking a road trip.” Evidently he’s planning on DC. “Would you be up for a visit early to mid-week?” he writes. After MONTHS of silence, he wants to come. I haven’t written back.
Dear Japan Man, you are four years too late. And I’m worth so much more than time killed.
It has not been a winning week for relationships around here. But perhaps, perhaps there is hope. The PhD smartie takes but a day to respond. Saieth he, “you write the greatest e-mails.” Indeed I do! Well, most of the time, anyway. This is promising. We’ll see. Stay tuned.

6 comments
Comments feed for this article
May 26, 2009 at 9:18 am
notsojenny
oh man, the ex situation is such a tough one. it’s seems (from what you’ve said) that he’s not really happy and he just feel responsible. that’s obviously not going to work out well… until he sees it he’s just going to keep going in that same direction though (and he may never see it clearly)
as far as the girl who got engaged, i understand. we were just talking about this the other day, how we don’t always understand other people’s relationships. i could never be in the same marriage that my best friend, even my sister, is in. i would never be happy, but they are. and that’s all that matters. we’re all happy/comfortable with different things… sometimes it’s so difficult to see what they see though and i totally get it.
and last, but not least, Japan Man – hit the road jack. that’s not cool of him. and if it were me i’d have some reason i couldn’t meet up with him, just to save yourself from whatever heartache & trouble he’s trying to hand deliver.
but the guy on the India trip… can’t wait to hear more!!
May 26, 2009 at 12:16 pm
tiadimo
You have learned so much from your past relationships and instead of coming out of them damaged and deranged, you have handled things with grace and have developed a deeper faith. I think that’s why your story is inspiring!
I have a feeling that most of your friends value your advice so if you have something you feel you need to say to them, maybe you should just go for it, especially with respect to your ex. It sounds like it he reaching for help and probably needs all the reinforcing he can get.
I am so glad you are putting your foot down with the JapanMan… I am sorry but his behavior is absolutely unacceptable! I am still SO excited about your India trip; cannot wait to hear more about the trip plans (and PhD on the plane who immediately picks up on your amazing writing talent is an added bonus).
May 26, 2009 at 4:34 pm
Cargirl
Now this blog pretty much demands comments from the peanut gallery!
Your friend moving in with the nutter probably feels he can fix her. Sadly, he’ll have to learn on his own – make his own mistakes – before he realizes, he can not fix her.
“Dear Japan Man, you are four years too late. And I’m worth so much more than time killed.”…………..please stick to this mantra!!! You ARE worth so much more. I would suggest not writing him back, but if you feel you must (you seem the polite type), I would make a terse, simple, “sorry I am not available” reply. Big message – itty bitty email space.
Good luck with PhD man. Honesty is always attractive, and I’m sure he sees it as a healthy thing that you’ve reflected and learned from your past relationships – it makes you a better person!
May 27, 2009 at 1:16 pm
Mel
I know a guy who had a lot of the same scenario going on with the nut job and he just likes the drama. I don’t even say this as a joke b/c hearing his history all the girls he has seen are a little (alot) nutty. You can already see the plane going down in flames but what can you do?
As for India… I am so excited for you!!!! I can see it all play out …. exotic country, smart man by your side seeing the world! Oh yeah and it helps that he is catholic too.
I’ve messed up a lot of relationships and to be honest with you I think the reason I finally decided to do my confirmation is b/c I am finally at peace with everything in my life. Hi I’m Mel I screwed up my life until now and this is the first time it seems normal so I decided to come to church and find God.
And Japan Man can suck it.
May 27, 2009 at 8:11 pm
LiLu
OMG re: the second one! I have a girlfriend just like that… I dread the day they announce their engagement. He’s a good guy; he’s even a GREAT guy… he’s just not enough for HER.
Sigh.
May 28, 2009 at 12:13 pm
DanceintheRain
This India trip man sounds interesting! I’m anxious to hear more about him!
Also, I don’t think (from what you’ve shared) that Japan man is worth your effort. I say that you’re ‘busy’ on any of the days that he’s in town.