“I’m staying with some of the bridesmaids,” I told my mom. “Some of them are single, or they aren’t staying with their boyfriends, or something. Anyway, they’re getting a suite, and they said I’m more than invited to hang out with them!”

Of course not. Of course I’m staying with him. My powers of on-the-spot fabrication still impress me, though.

Nothing slips past my mom, and I’ve learned to preemptively seal my stories with an impenetrable water-tight click. I suspect she knows what really goes on; no one that smart is that blind. It’s just a little dance we do.

“He was the one with the girlfriend. That Helen,” she says. “Ellen,” I correct, but to myself I’m thinking, Really? I mentioned that? I named her out loud, to my mother? Really? “You definitely had a thing for him,” she adds, and I cringe. “I didn’t realize you were still in touch.” (Of course not, mom; I forgot you even knew he existed).

The Japan Man did not come on his road trip. He is, however, in a wedding this weekend up in Pennsylvania, and a bizarre twist of chance conversation found me agreeing to be his date.

“I’ll meet you at the hotel,” he said. “I’ll have a key for you.”

My stomach has been in knots all day. Productivity, it’s fair to say, has not been high.

I’m well aware of all that’s at stake here, and how this story reads. Adopting an objective eye, I want to smack myself. “You’re undoing all of your good work!” I’d cry. “You should have said no! Just practice with me—N-O!” I’d coach. Better yet, “This guy has a toxic hold on you, and if you cave you’re going to mess up the future of your relationships, possibly forever!” I see that. Really, I do. But I feel, too; I feel so much more than logic can justify. This one was different. He was different.

I’m good at writing dismissive f-you-too e-mails, and I’m good at unilaterally severing ties. Writing JAPAN MAN CAN SUCK IT, in all caps, to all of my friends. I’m good at telling myself that it’s over, and moving on.

Thing is, it hasn’t worked. Not really. Not with him. For nearly five years, he’s been in my thoughts, that one hanging “what if” that has veritably haunted everything since. I was naïve and stupid, yes. I loved him in a very real way, though, in that land of once upon a time, and while it sounds cheesy, I really think it’s closure that I’m after. In order to move forward, be it with the smartie PhD or otherwise, this—this japan business—it has to end.

As random as some things seem, I often wonder if they aren’t really just part of a bigger pattern we don’t see. Maybe this has to happen right now. Maybe it’s the only way. Maybe I’m finally in a place where I’m ready to see him and not have my heart go all aflutter like I’m 22 again. Not expect to round the corner and smack into him, off in an airport somewhere, and fall in love all princess-style. Maybe it’s finally ripened and I’m ready to let go; maybe this has to be flushed out with finality to make way for something new, something even bigger. Maybe I’m just cursed.

Hotel key or no, though, he will be swiftly informed of a major policy-shift since our last encounter. I no longer sleep with strangers. Period. (goal 1).

Neither do I drink to the point of poor choices. (goal 2).

And my heart is locked behind a spiked tower, with a moat, and some fierce crocodiles that eat men who come in without first passing a rigorous screening process. (goal 3).

It’s just something that I have to do. I have to know what happens. I have to know who we are.